Relativity – The Special and The General Theory. A Popular
Exposition.
Anyone who reads or writes science fiction gets caught up in
relativity some time or other, whether it is with faster than light
travel, warp drives, time travel, wormholes, the bending of space and
time or any of a number of other fun concepts. Wouldn't it be nice to
actually know some of the real theory behind all of this? Some people
are put off reading about the subject because much of what is written
is heavily mathematical. Worry no more. This book by Albert Einstein
himself is aimed at those who want to understand the concepts but
don't want to get bogged down in mathematics.
I have just re-read this book, and just like the last time I read
it some twenty years ago, I am both impressed and grateful that a man
of such awe-inspiring intellectual prowess took the trouble to
explain this complex subject to me. It's almost as though he is in
the room talking to a non-mathematician, and gently, one step at a
time, starting with the fundamentals, building up the ideas that make
this impressive set of theories.
I thought to tell you what the book is and who it is aimed at, but
I cannot put it better than Albert Einstein's own words in his
preface of December 1916.
“
The present book is intended, as far
as possible, to give an exact insight into the theory of Relativity
to those readers who, from a general scientific and philosophical
point of view, are interested in the theory, but who are not
conversant with the mathematical apparatus of theoretical physics.
The work presumes a standard of education corresponding to that of a
university matriculation examination, and, despite the shortness of
the book, a fair amount of patience and force of will on the part of
the reader. The author has spared himself no pains in his endeavour
to present the main ideas in the simplest and most intelligible form,
and on the whole, in the sequence and connection in which they
actually originated. In the interest of clearness, it appeared to me
inevitable that I should repeat myself frequently, without paying the
slightest attention to the elegance of the presentation. I adhered
scrupulously to the precept of that brilliant theoretical physicist
L. Boltzmann, according to whom matters of elegance ought to be left
to the tailor and to the cobbler. I make no pretence of having
withheld from the reader difficulties which are inherent to the
subject. On the other hand, I have purposely treated the empirical
physical foundations of the theory in a "step-motherly"
fashion, so that readers unfamiliar with physics may not feel like
the wanderer who was unable to see the forest for the trees. May the
book bring some one a few happy hours of suggestive thought!”
The book is written in 32 short chapters, most of which are less
than four pages in length. The chapters are bite-sized chunks, and
each adds a new step in understanding of the theory. The chapters are
organised into three parts and three appendices:
Part I The Special Theory of Relativity
Part II The General Theory of Relativity
Part III Considerations on the Universe as a Whole
Appendix I Simple Derivation of the Lorentz Transformation
Appendix II Minkowski's Four-dimensional Space (“World”)
Appendix III The Experimental Confirmation of the General Theory
of Relativity
Part I The Special Theory of Relativity
One of the great things about special relativity is you can
understand it with no more than high school mathematics.
Einstein is rigorous in his approach, and argues that any
definition that cannot be verified by measurement is meaningless. He
begins with what he calls “the Principle of Relativity (in the
restricted sense)”, which states:
If, relative to K, K' is a uniformly moving coordinate system
devoid of rotation, then natural phenomena run their course with
respect to K' according to exactly the same general laws as with
respect to K.
He then goes on to use an example of a railway train moving
relative to the embankment to show that the above principle of
relativity is in conflict with the statement that the speed of light
is a constant in vacuum. He concludes that we must either abandon the
so-called “Principle of Relativity (in the restricted sense)” or
the assertion that the speed of light in vacuum is constant – or we
can develop a theory that reconciles the two. That theory is the
Special Theory of Relativity.
The argument of the text then proceeds towards a derivation of the
Lorentz transformation. At this point he states its mathematical
representation, and refers the reader to Appendix I if they want a
derivation.
In essence, the Lorentz transformation shows that if we measure
distance or time for an event in one reference frame, then the
measured distance or time in a different reference frame (for the
same event) depend on the relative velocity of the two reference
frames.
This is all well and good, but it only applies if we constrain
ourselves to uniform rectilinear and non-rotary motion, and that's
what brings us on to Part II.
Part II The General Theory of Relativity
So, what if we remove this last constraint, and don't limit ourselves to uniform rectilinear and non-rotary motion?
Unlike the special theory of relativity, a full understanding of
the general theory of relativity requires some really tricky
mathematics, and is not for the faint hearted.
Einstein argues that gravity acts by means of a gravitational
field, and that the law governing the field must be a “perfectly
definite one.” With consideration, he concludes that “the same
quantity of a body manifests itself according to circumstances as
'inertia' or as 'weight'”. This leads to the conclusion that an
observer, given no other clues, cannot tell the difference between a
downward gravitational field and an upward uniform acceleration.
Using an example of a rotating disc he shows that the classical
propositions of Euclidean geometry cannot hold in a gravitational
field. Hence the idea of a straight line loses its meaning. He
overcomes this by using Gaussian coordinates rather than cartesian
coordinates – leaving cartesian coordinates as simply a special
case.
He goes to some trouble to demonstrate how space-time might be
conceived this way. The space-time continuum of the General Theory of
Relativity is not a Euclidian continuum, so instead we use four
dimensional Gaussian coordinates.
Following on from this he describes space-time using a non-rigid
reference body, moving and altering form in any way, and in which the
time, measured at indefinitely close points, vary by indefinitely
small amounts. He refers to this reference body as a “mollusc”.
I have necessarily abbreviated the description so far, and in so
doing, I have probably made it sound either hokey or nonsensical.
Reading this book will show that to be a shortfall of my description
rather than Einstein's explanation. He goes on to formulate the
General Principle of Relativity using a non-mathematical description.
It would be pointless for me to attempt an abbreviated statement of
his case, since his words are already just that, and presented
without the aid of mathematics. The interested reader should
certainly read Einstein's words.
It's fair to say that in Part II, Einstein explains the general
theory of relativity reasonably well, considering that he is avoiding
the mathematics, and attempting to convey the concepts to an educated
layman.
The rest of Part II, and a short Part III
The rest of Part II and a short Part III offer interesting
discussions of how the General Theory of Relativity helps with, for
example, explaining the following:
The 43 arcsecond per century discrepancy between the observed
orbit of Mercury and the predictions of classical mechanics.
The existence of a universe that is finite yet unbounded.
The structure of space. Given that the behaviour of measuring rods
and clocks is influenced by gravitational fields, the distribution of
matter cannot be described using Euclidean geometry with complete
accuracy. He explains what the General Theory of Relativity tells us
about the structure of space.
Conclusion
I sincerely hope I haven't managed to make this work sound either
dry or too difficult to read. It is elegantly written, and well
explained. He doesn't introduce any concepts without explaining what
they mean, and in the end, the reader cannot but have an appreciation
of the wonders of the special and general theories of relativity.